• Question: on plastic water bottles they say that the water is natural and pure, i thought that only distilled water was pure and natural not bottled. Is this true?

    Asked by eh8127 to Hywel, Joseph, Poonam on 24 Jun 2010 in Categories: .
    • Photo: Dr Hywel Jones

      Dr Hywel Jones answered on 24 Jun 2010:


      Thats a very good Q. Next time you pay £1 for some water think about it. Most water derived from natural sources, whether it is from springs or rivers and reservoirs will have smalls amount of dissolved minerals from the rocks that the water has passed over. In fact this is the major selling point for “mineral waters”. Some people think the minerals are good for you but in fact the modern day diet is good enough that we don’t really need to worry about it. The VIctorians were really in to their Spas and mineral waters but its now generally regarded as not really that important.
      Pure water is indeed the distilled type. In fact in our lab we have a special machine that produces very pure water, called de-ionised water, which we use in experiments. Even the stuff dissolved in tap water can affect our experiments.
      Be warned though, if you drank enough very pure water quickly enough you could get ill as you dilute your bodies minerals to a dangerous level (we all need stuff like sodium and potassium for our cells to function). This is also true of normal water and some teenagers have died this way. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leah_Betts

    • Photo: Joseph Cook

      Joseph Cook answered on 24 Jun 2010:


      Distilled water contains very little of anything other than water, so it is pretty much ‘pure’ water. It’s useful for science, but pure water isn’t actually very good for you if you drink it because it leaches the minerals out of your cells. Tap water and bottled water has a little bit of different types of salt in it so you don’t have this problem – it’s such a small amount that you can’t really taste it though.

      The bottled water is ‘pure’ and ‘natural’ because it has come from a spring and so needs very little processing and usually contains useful minerals from the nearby rocks. But there’s nothing wrong with tap water, it’s fine to drink in this country.

Comments